Film Review: Swing Kids

 

  • Actors: Robert Sean Leonard, Christian Bale, Frank Whaley, Barbara Hershey, Tushka Bergen
  • Director: Thomas Carter
  • Rated: PG-13 (Parental Guidance Suggested)
  • Studio: Hollywood Pictures / Buena Vista Home Entertainment
  • Release Year: 1993
  • Run Time:112 minutes

    I do not usually trust Hollywood movies for historical accuracy or realistic non-American characters, even if I enjoy them as entertainment. But my German friend and beta-reader Arnika Kiani, who generously checks my drafts for German authenticity, sent me Swing Kids together with other German history movies.

    I watched Swing Kids, and it was well worth it. The setting is Hamburg in the late 1930’s, around the time of the annexation of Sudetenland and the Anschluss of Austria. The movie shows us a less known part of the Third Reich history: the Swing Youth, a German teenage subculture that emerged in an opposition to the dogmatic Hitler Youth system.  Swing Kids, as they called themselves, listened to jazz and swing music, mimicked British and American fashions, including zoot suits, and danced away at covert parties in clubs and cafes.

    The movie shows how a group of friends, fans of swing and jitterbug, collides with the Nazi regime. Because of a stupid prank, one of the teenage boys has to join the Hitler Youth to avoid further trouble. In solidarity with him, one of his friends joins the Hitler Youth too. At the same time the third friend, a misfit of sorts, develops a blatant defiance of the Nazi order. As we follow the protagonists, we can see how the Nazi ideology affected each of them and the people around, and how personal circumstances could contribute to one’s acceptance or rejection of Nazism. While one of the friends in the Hitler Youth loathes its teachings, the other, on the contrary, falls into them because the Hitler Youth fulfills his yearning for belonging and companionship which his own family failed to provide.

    Although some episodes are reminiscent of a glossy magazine, the movie does provide a glimpse of German life just before the war. It made me realize how the regime validated and cultivated physical violence. The Hitler Youth groups were routinely mustered to help police round up and beat swing kids at secret dance parties. The scenes of the Hitler Youth training and indoctrination helped me visualize the past experiences of my German protagonist who has been heavily influenced by the Hitler Youth.

    Some episodes looked eerily familiar to me. The movie shows how the Hitler Youth leaders taught the children to report their relatives for criticism of the regime, thus nurturing German versions of  Pavlik Morozov, a child hero exalted in the Soviet Union for turning in his father. As a schoolgirl, I read a fair share of textbook stories and verses glorifying Pavlik Morozov in the 1970’s-1980’s. Our school teachers lectured us why it was immoral to follow American fashions and wear jeans, dance to the evil Western music and chew gum. Of course, it was much more benign in my time than in Nazi Germany or the 1930’s Soviet Union. We were under no threat of a jail or labor camp. The worst we faced was a reprimand, a note to the parents or a poor behavior mark in the grade report.

    Swing Kids has a lot of good acting, including a charming Gestapo official played by Kenneth Branagh. The swing dance cameos are carefree and energizing, in a sharp contrast with the scenes of the Hitler Youth drills. The movie shows nuances and shades of gray in human behavior, which makes it ever more interesting to watch. Contrary to the Hollywood custom of happy endings, the finale is dark and foreboding, although some might find it too dramatized.

My ROW80 progress:

  • Not much writing and revising progress, which is not good. I could say that things were too busy at work or that I had a difficult weekend because of teenage dramas in the household, but I do need to learn to carve out my writing time and space;
  • While pondering my review for Swing Kids, I checked some facts on the Hitler Youth online which helped my characterizations.

This week’s ROW80 goals:

  • Jealously guard my writing time and space;
  • Start reading The collapse of the German war economy, 1944-1945: Allied air power and the German National Railway by Alfred C. Mierzejewski, which is ready for pickup at my library.
Advertisements

9 comments on “Film Review: Swing Kids

  1. KM Huber says:

    Yet another fine post, Svetlana. I have always been interested in the 1930s-40s, and I may have seen this film (am a fan of Barbara Hershey and think I remember her in it) but I’m going to look for it. Generally, I don’t remember films and have been told that I am consistent in my response to them, each time I see them. Did not know about Pavlik Morozov; once again, I learn by reading your blog.

    Karen

  2. Diane Davis says:

    I found your blog by following a picture posted on Axis History Forum. I really like your blog and all the information you are passing along through your research.
    I too am working on a Berlin WWII book, but a book in poetry for middle age/young adult readers on Berlin’s rubble women. From the eyes of the trummerfrauen (working title) is a series of poems looking at the hardships,horrors and hopes of the women of Berlin, right after the war. Although the rubble women have been cherished in Germany, most Americans have never heard of them. I’d like to introduce students to a time when women led the way in rebuilding their country. I’ve found some great pictures of rubble women and read several accounts of women living in Berlin in 1945, but I haven’t found any books that focused on the personal aspects of rebuilding the city. Instead, I’ve found lots of statistics on how many rations they were given or how the city was divided up in work details.
    I was wondering if you’ve found any books in your research that talk about working on the lines, relations with other women on the lines, etc.
    I’d appreciate any direction that you can lead me. Best of luck with your book, it sounds fantastic.
    Thanks,
    Diane

  3. Diane Davis says:

    Arnika,
    Thank you for your help. Through my research, it seems that the allies had different curcumstances for the trummenfrauen, depending on what part of the city you were from. Some women started clearing areas on their own, well before the allies considered it. Others set the women to work right away, and others offered it as an incentive for more food. We tend to think of Berlin and trummerfrauen as one, but it seems that it was quite diverse depending on where you lived.

    Unfortunately, I do not speak German. I just have an intense interest in this situation and some family connections. I am pleased however, at the number of books that are available to me now, compared to ten years ago when there was practically nothing I could get. And there was nearly nothing on the internet then as well. Now so many things are translated into English. I have learned so much by following one link after another.

    I feel I’m gaining an understanding of what it must have been like to live through this time, but wish I could have knowledge of the human aspect of it all.
    Facts don’t tell the whole story. What did the women gossip about? Did they go to the lines with their friends, become friends by working side by side? Did they protect one another from soldiers? Did they complain the whole time or were they thinking about their new futures? So many things to wonder about. If you do see anything in English, or have a chance to talk to a former trummenfrauen, I’d love to hear about it.
    Thanks for your help,
    Diane

    • Arnika: My thanks for your help!

      Diane: Thank you for visiting my blog. This book, A Woman in Berlin by Anonymous, includes a short account of the author’s experience clearing rubble. Other than that, I haven’t come across any detailed personal accounts by Trummerfrauen in English.

      Unfortunately, many great sources are available in German only. I have forgotten the language almost completely since I studied it many years ago and only for a short time. Now I’m deciphering Google translations and wishing I put more effort in my German studies!

  4. Diane Davis says:

    thank you for your help. I appreciate any leads I get.
    Looking forward to reading your future posts as well.
    Diane

  5. Beth Camp says:

    Thanks for posting to the IWW Writing List. I very much appreciate the clarity of your description of how you organize research into two phases, and now, here, that weekly goal setting for the blog. Very nice!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s